Whoa. Good and bad design? I can't help but question, who am I to say what qualifies good and bad design? I'm barely ankle deep in this, but hey, Ira Glass says I have good taste.
I guess I feel like the qualifying factor for design would be it's ability to communicate. When everything is said and done, that is really what design is trying to do.
Designs I feel do communicate:
©Pelá - Brazilian Festival
I LOVE this poster series. How Brazilian is this?
Despite not being able to read the information due to language barriers, it definitely communicates to me.
It squeals with the chaos and vibrancy that identifies Brazil.
"Osmosis" from "Domestic Reliquary" by Daniel W. Coburn
I think that the alteration in this image speaks profound truths in anyone that has been a small child in a public pool. The sense of uneasiness transmits to the audience, and I love the way you can't entirely tell if the child is screaming, yawning, or about to smile.
I really enjoy the composition of this magazine cover. The logo fits into the sky and just barely touches the tips of the mountains, and the text turned on its side adds some visual interest for me. There's a weirdness about the photo that interests me also- the sun is shining and the water looks calm, which sounds like the recipe for a perfect beach day, but the man's face is concealed by the wave except for his mouth, which is underwater. Is he relaxing or sinking? I like that the photo isn't straightforward and makes me ask questions.
http://whereisthecool.com/post/31079471125
Bad:
http://kotaku.com/the-rip-off-controvesy-over-the-tokyo-olympics-logo-1720796383
Tokyo Olympics Logo Controversy
Even without the considerations of plagiarism, I am not fond of the Tokyo Olympics logo. I feel like it fails to communicate the unity, celebration, and action that the olympic games represent. That being said, the very very similar logo for the theatre does a better job of conveying the classic atmosphere I would expect in a theatre.
Courtesy of the bakery's website.
This logo fails to meet its potential. I feel like the type choice doesn't mesh well with the illustrations, and I think so much more personality could be incorporated. Not a terrible logo, but definitely not something I'd consider good.
The Joker Typographic Posters by Felipe Collazo on Behance
The type screams Nascar, not the joker. There's a misplaced speed and the structure of the type adds nothing to the phrase. It feels out of place and confusing.